Statistics from Altmetric.com
If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.
Central to the argument of ‘Biodefense and the Production of Knowledge: Rethinking the Problem’ are claims that
the vast majority of ethical debate about biodefense research to date has focused on the dual use problem, and
the focus of ethical discussion of dual-use research has been on the need to strike ‘a proper balance of only two dominant values: biosecurity and “open science”’ —the idea being that ‘under current conditions other values can and ought to be ignored because the stakes are so high’.1
With regard to (2), Buchanan and Kelley's main point is that policy making regarding biodefense and dual use should be seen as an ‘optimisation problem’—the aim should be to achieve the greater good of society, where all relevant values are taken into account, rather than limiting attention to just two values—security and open science—in particular. While, as other commentators have argued, it is questionable whether these authors have provided an accurate account of ethical discussion of biodefense and dual use to date, in this brief commentary my purpose is to argue that the values of security and open science should themselves be seen as proxies for other values (comprising the greater good of society) and that solution to …
Competing interests None.
Provenance and peer review Commissioned; internally peer reviewed.
Read the full text or download the PDF:
Other content recommended for you
- Biodefence and the production of knowledge: rethinking the problem
- Great expectations—ethics, avian flu and the value of progress
- Commentary on ‘Biodefence and the production of knowledge: rethinking the problem’
- The ethics of biosafety considerations in gain-of-function research resulting in the creation of potential pandemic pathogens
- Biosecurity and the division of cognitive labour
- Is dual use of nicotine products and cigarettes associated with smoking reduction and cessation behaviours? A prospective study in England
- US board gives green light to publication of bird flu studies it previously blocked
- The ethics of sexual reorientation: what should clinicians and researchers do?
- Dual use opportunity and public health infrastructure
- Public awareness, acceptability and risk perception about infectious diseases dual-use research of concern: a cross-sectional survey