Article Text
Statistics from Altmetric.com
The articles in this issue direct our attention to the role of concepts in medical ethics. The issue includes research that defines a concept,1 research that applies concepts to illuminate the moral aspects of various elements of medicine,2 3 and research investigating the appropriate set of concepts to teach medical students.4
In their in-depth exploration of the concept of disease in this issue, Powell and Scarffe argue that our understanding of a concept should be ‘tailored to the role that the concept plays in the institutional settings in which it is deployed’.1 Their methodology takes seriously the institutional context in which a concept operates. This approach to thinking about concepts is potentially applicable very broadly in medical ethics. What is the institutional role that a concept plays? What is the work that we need the concept to do?
The feature article by Powell and Scarffe proposes a new definition of a foundational concept in medicine, that of disease. On their view, ‘a biomedical state is a disease only if it implicates a biological dysfunction that is, or would be, properly disvalued’.1 They describe their definition as involving both a moral criterion (of being ‘properly disvalued’) and a biological criterion (of biological dysfunction).
A number of commentators engage with Powell and Scarffe’s proposal. Tekin focuses on the moral criterion, through the example of grief and depression. …
Other content recommended for you
- Training healthcare professionals as moral case deliberation facilitators: evaluation of a Dutch training programme
- Moral ambivalence towards the Cancer Drugs Fund
- Measuring the impact of clinical ethics support services: further points for consideration
- Meeting the needs of underserved populations: setting the agenda for more inclusive citizen science of medicine
- ‘Rethinking “Disease”: a fresh diagnosis and a new philosophical treatment’
- Objectives and outcomes of clinical ethics services: a Delphi study
- Resourcefulness of an empirically informed and thickly normative account of disease
- Is UNESCO’s Undergraduate Bioethics Integrated Curriculum (Medical) fit for purpose?
- Clarifying the best interests standard: the elaborative and enumerative strategies in public policy-making
- Developing a framework to incorporate real-world evidence in cancer drug funding decisions: the Canadian Real-world Evidence for Value of Cancer Drugs (CanREValue) collaboration