Article Text
Statistics from Altmetric.com
- Transplantation
- Dead donor rule
- Definition/Determination of Death
- Vital organ donation
- Donation/Procurement of Organs/Tissues
The recent consensus statement from the American Thoracic Society perfectly captured the central ethical dilemma in organ procurement: ‘the tension between the need for both “live organs” and a “dead donor” has required the development of very explicit criteria for declaring the “moment” of death, despite the absence of a biological basis for this degree of precision’.1
As such, what is most notable about the paper by Dalle Ave et al2 is their description of how the transplantation community has twisted themselves into pretzels creating ethical justifications for increasingly contrived ways to extract functioning organs from people deemed to be dead. In so doing, they are sustaining ethical myths and illusions that have ceased to have any face validity in terms of common sense clinical practice. Let me explain.
The driving force behind these contortionist efforts is the so-called dead donor rule (DDR), which seeks to establish a bright line, or ethical firewall, between the dying process and organ procurement.3 But this bright line has always been an illusion. In donation following the diagnosis of brain death, for example, the living body of a person with a devastating brain injury is fully supported until after the organs can be removed. In donation after …
Footnotes
Competing interests None declared.
Provenance and peer review Commissioned; internally peer reviewed.
Linked Articles
- Current controversy
Read the full text or download the PDF:
Other content recommended for you
- A narrative review of the empirical evidence on public attitudes on brain death and vital organ transplantation: the need for better data to inform policy
- The dead donor rule: effect on the virtuous practice of medicine
- Death and organ donation: back to the future
- An analysis of heart donation after circulatory determination of death
- What makes killing wrong?
- Does it matter that organ donors are not dead? Ethical and policy implications
- Death and legal fictions
- On the ethical permissibility of in situ reperfusion in cardiac transplantation after the declaration of circulatory death
- Organ donation after medical assistance in dying or cessation of life-sustaining treatment requested by conscious patients: the Canadian context
- Abandoning the Dead Donor Rule