Genetic screening for breast cancer and other diseases poses major personal and psychological challenges for persons facing the prospect of testing. The personal report of those dilemmas by a woman considering BRCA1 screening who had had a lumpectomy for breast cancer and whose mother had died from that disease is presented here. Commentaries by a bioethicist and a genetics counselor show further complexities in the testing experience which persons considering testing and those providing them will need to confront.