Abstract
The Royal Dutch Medical Association recently completed a researchproject aimed at investigating how guidelines for `appropriatemedical care' should be construed. The project took as a startingpoint that explicit attention should be given to ethical andpolitical considerations in addition to data about costs andeffectiveness. In the project, two research groups set out todesign guidelines and cost-effectiveness analyses (CEAs) for twocircumscribed medical areas (angina pectoris and majordepression). Our third group was responsible for the normativeanalysis. We undertook an explorative, qualitative pilot study ofthe normative considerations that played a role in constructingthe guidelines and CEAs, and simultaneously interviewedspecialists about the normative considerations that guided theirdiagnostic and treatment decisions. Explicating normativeconsiderations, we argue, is important democratically: the issuesat stake should not be left to decision analysts and guidelinedevelopers to decide. Moreover, it is a necessary condition for asuccessful implementation of such tools: those who draw uponthese tools will only accept them when they can recognizethemselves in the considerations implied. Empirical normativeanalysis, we argue, is a crucial tool in developing guidelinesfor appropriate medical care.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Anand, P. (1999) QALYs and the Integration of Claims in Health-Care Rationing. Health Care Analysis 7, 239-253.
Anspach, R.R. (1993) Deciding Who Lives. Fateful Choices in the Intensive Care Nursery. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Ashmore, M., Mulkay, M. and Pinch, T. (1989) Health and Efficiency: A Sociology of Health Economics. Milton Keynes: Open University Press.
Atkinson, P. (1995) Medical Talk and Medical Work. London: Sage.
Beck, U., Giddens, A. and Lash, S. (1994) Reflexive Modernization. Standford: Stanford University Press.
Berg, M. (1992) The Construction of Medical Disposals. Medical Sociology and Medical Problem Solving in Clinical Practice. Sociology of Health and Illness 14, 151-180.
Berg, M. (1997a) Problems and Promises of the Protocol. Social Science and Medicine 44, 1081-1088.
Berg, M. (1997b) Rationalizing Medical Work. Decision Support Techniques and Medical Practices. Cambridge: MIT Press.
Cicourel, A.V. (1986) The Reproduction of Objective Knowledge: Common Sense Reasoning in Medical Decision Making. In G. Böhme and N. Stehr (Eds.), The Knowledge Society (pp. 87-122). Dordrecht: Reidel.
Clancy, C.M. and Kamerow, D.B. (1996) Evidence-Based Medicine Meets Cost-Effectiveness Analysis. Journal of the American Medical Association 276, 329-330.
Cotton, P. (1992) 'Basic Benefits' have Many Variations, Tend to Become Political Issues. Journal of the American Medical Association 268, 2139-2141.
de Bruijn, E., Klazinga, N.S. and Dillman, R.J.M. (1998) Passend kiezen in de gezond-heidszorg? Medisch Contact.
Deber, R.B. (1992) Translating Technology Assessment into Policy: Conceptual Issues and Tough Choices. International Journal of Technology Assessment in Health Care 8, 131-137.
Dickenson, D.L. (1999) Can Medical Criteria Settle Priority-Setting Debates? The Need for Ethical Analysis. Health Care Analysis 7, 131-137.
Drummond, M., Brandt, A., Luce, B. and Rovira, J. (1993) Standardizing Methodologies for Economic Evaluzation in Health Care. International Journal of Technology Assessment in Health Care 9, 26-36.
Eddy, D.M. (1990) The Challenge. Journal of the American Medical Association 263, 287-290.
Eddy, D.M. (1992) Applying Cost-Effectiveness Analysis. The Inside Story. Journal of the American Medical Association 268, 2575-2582.
Eddy, D.M. (1993) Three Battles to Watch in the 1990s. Journal of the American Medical Association 270, 520-526.
Elsinga, E. and Rutten, F.F.H. (1997) Economic Evaluation in Support of National Health Policy: The Case of The Netherlands. Social Science and Medicine 45, 605-620.
Emery, D.D. and Schneiderman, L.J. (1989) Cost-Effectiveness Analysis in Health Care. Hastings Center Report 19, 8-13.
Feinstein, A.R. (1994) Clinical Judgment Revisited: The Distraction of Quantitative Models. Annals of Internal Medicine 120, 799-805.
Gifford, F. (1996) Outcomes Research and Practice Guidelines: Upstream Issues for Downstream Users. Hastings Center Report 26, 38-44.
Granata, A.V. and Hillman, A.L. (1998) Competing Practice Guidelines: Using Cost-Effectiveness Analysis to Make Optimal Decisions. Annals of Internal Medicine 128, 56-63.
Grimshaw, J., Freemantle, N., Wallace, S., Russell, I., Hurwitz, B., Watt, I., Long, A. and Sheldon, T. (1995) Developing and Implementing Clinical Practice Guidelines. Quality in Health Care 4, 55-64.
Halpern, J. (1995) Can the Development of Practice Guidelines Safeguard Patient Values? Journal of Law and Ethics 23, 75-81.
Heitman, E. (1999) Ethical Issues in Technology Assessment — Conceptual Categories and Procedural Considerations. International Journal of Technology Assessment in Health Care 14, 544-566.
Holm, S. (1998) Goodbye to the Simple Solutions: The Second Phase of Priority Setting in Health Care. British Medical Journal 317, 1000-1002.
Jennings, B. (1990) Ethics and Ethnography in Neonatal Intensive Care. In G. Weisz (Ed.), Social Science Perspectives on Medical Ethics (pp. 261-272). Dordrecht: Kluwer Academic Publishers.
Kassirer, J.P. and Kopelman, R.I. (1990) Diagnosis and Decisions by Algorithms. Hospital Practice 25, 23-24, 27, 31.
Klein, R. (1998) Puzzling Out Priorities. Why We Must Acknowledge that Rationing is a Political Process. British Medical Journal 317, 959-60.
Kosecoff, J., Kanouse, D.E., Rogers, W.H., McCloskey, L., Winslow, C.M. and Brook, R.H. (1987) Effects of the National Institutes of Health Consensus Development Program on Physician Practice. Journal of the American Medical Association 258, 2708-2713.
Mason, J., Eccles, M., Freemantle, N. and Drummond, M. (1999) A Framework for Incorporating Cost-Effectiveness in Evidence-Based Clinical Practice Guidelines. Health Policy 47, 37-52.
Mol, A. and Elsman, B. (1996) Detecting Disease and Designing Treatment. Duplex and the Diagnosis of Diseased Leg Vessels. Sociology of Health and Illness 18, 609-631.
Nord, E. (1999) Towards Cost-Value Analysis in Health Care? Health Care Analysis 7, 167-175.
Perrow, C. (1984) Normal Accidents. Living with High Risk Technologies. New York: Basic Books.
Redman, B.K. (1994) Clinical Practic Guidelines as Tools of Public Policy: Conflicts of Purpose, Issues of Autonomy and Justice. Journal of Clinical Ethics 5, 303-309. Riesenberg, D. (1989) Economics is Everybody's Business. Journal of the American Medical Association 262, 2897.
Rigter, H., Willemse, G., Tiemeier, H., Lemmens, F., Smit, F. and Hutschemaekers, G. (2000) Establishing Appropriate Indications for Treatment of Mood Disorder in The Netherlands Using a Formal Group Judgment Method. Social Psychiatry and Psychiatric Epidemiology, in press.
Rothman, D.J. (1991) Strangers at the Bedside: A History of How Law and Bioethics Transformed Medical Decision Making. New York: Basic Books.
Sackett, D.L. and Rosenberg, W.M.C. (1995) The Need for Evidence-Based Medicine. Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine 88, 620-624.
Sclove, R.E. (1995) Democracy and Technology. New York: Guilford Press.
Starr, P. (1982) The Social Transformation of American Medicine. New York: Basic Books.
Strauss, A., Fagerhaugh, S., Suczek, B. and Wieder, C. (1985) Social Organization of Medical Work. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Tanenbaum, S.J. (1993) What Physicians Know. New England Journal of Medicine 329, 1268-1271.
Tanenbaum, S.J. (1994) Knowing and Acting in Medical Practice: The Epistemological Politics of Outcomes Research. Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law 19, 27-44.
Timmermans, S., Bowker, G.C. and Star, S.L. (1998) The Architecture of Difference: Visibility, Controllability, and Comparability in Building a Nursing Intervention Classification. In M. Berg and A. Mol (Eds.), Differences in Medicine. Unraveling Practices, Techniques and Bodies (pp. 202-228). Durham: Duke University Press.
van Hout, B., Goes, E.S., Grijseels, E.W.M. and Quarles van Ufford, M.A. (1999) Economic Evaluation in the Field of Cardiology: Theory and Practice. Progress in Cardiovascular Diseases 42, 167-173.
Williams, A. (1992) Cost-Effectiveness Analysis: Is It Ethical? Journal of Medical Ethics 18, 7-11.
Williams, A. (1996) Qalys and Ethics: A Health Economist's Perspective. Social Science and Medicine 43, 1795-1804.
Williamson, C. (1992) Whose Standards? Consumer and Professional Standards in Health Care. Buckingham: Open University Press.
Woolf, S., Grol, R., Hutchinson, A., Eccles, M. and Grimshaw, J. (1999) Potential Benefits, Limitations, and Harms of Clinical Guidelines. British Medical Journal 318, 527-530.
Wynia, M.K. (1997) Economic Analyses, the Medical Commons, and Patients' Dilemmas: What is the Physician's Role? Journal of Investigative Medicine 45, 35-43.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Berg, M., ter Meulen, R. & van den Burg, M. Guidelines for Appropriate Care: The Importance of Empirical Normative Analysis. Health Care Analysis 9, 77–99 (2001). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1011307112091
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1011307112091