SupplementDifficulties of surgery in the developing world: a personal view
Section snippets
Situation at present
Surgery in the developing world is widely known to be done against a background of poverty, patients' low awareness of its possible benefits, and limited medical resources. Most patients live in villages, present with advanced disease, are malnourished, and cannot afford the cheapest medicines. Most surgeons (probably about 80% in most developing countries) work in cities and are reluctant to work in rural areas because there are no facilities for the operations for which they have been
Why is this so?
The main reason for this sad state of affairs is the lack of political will to improve matters in the health sector. Health is given low priority because the rich have most of their surgical needs met by private hospitals here or abroad. The poor are not organised enough to complain, so improvement of the health system is rarely an election issue. The underfunded public system pays its servants a pittance. Surgeons working for the Indian government earn about US$400 a month, a twentieth of what
What can be done?
Health should receive substantially more than the present level of less than 2% of the national budget. But even without this increase, there should be a rethinking of the kind of surgeons that developing countries need. These countries need three kinds of surgeons (panel 2) Surgeons for primary health centres, known perhaps as “general physicians and surgeons”, would, in addition to dealing with medical (non-surgical) problems, be able to repair a hernia, do a caesarean section, and set simple
Conclusions
If conditions are so difficult, why do so many surgeons continue to work here? The reason is that the difficulties are far outweighed by the pleasures and sense of achievement a surgeon gets by working in a developing country. There is little more satisfaction that a doctor can get than feeling useful and needed by one's own countrymen who have few other people to turn to for help. The problems may be vast and numerous but they are always interesting and admit medical as well as social
References (11)
Keyhole surgery
Lancet
(1994)- et al.
Incidence and estimated need of caesarean section, inguinal hernia repair, and operation for strangulated hernia in rural Africa
BMJ
(1984)Hospital surgery in rural Pakistan
Malignant lymphoma involving the jaws in Africa
J Laryngol Otol
(1965)
Cited by (17)
Simplified percutaneous large bore suprapubic cystostomy for acute urinary retention-A cost saving procedure
2014, African Journal of UrologyCitation Excerpt :This modified technique can be used to insert chosen Foley catheter of size 18 and 20 which has large enough drainage lumen while at the same time – are not too big to demand wider skin puncture-wounds. Cost of surgical procedures in low-resource economies has always been a hindering factor to access surgery due to the significant disparity between the financial status of most of the populace and the cost of surgery [11,12]. In our region, many patients with obstructed urination delay seeking medical help and end up presenting to the emergency department with urinary retention.
Plastic surgery and global health: How plastic surgery impacts the global burden of surgical disease
2010, Journal of Plastic, Reconstructive and Aesthetic SurgeryCitation Excerpt :Diseases amenable to surgical treatment account for an estimated 10%–15% of all admissions to hospitals in developing countries.5
Modified Suprapubic Prostatectomy Without Irrigation Is Safe
2010, UrologyCitation Excerpt :Esho's approach has not been widely adopted or incorporated into standard textbooks presumably due to a concern over the possible risks of such aggressive hydration and diuresis, particularly in elderly patients. Cost of surgical or medical treatment as a whole is a daily problem in many African countries and most other developing countries as a whole.13-15 With no effective medical insurance in most of these countries, patients have to bear the full burden of seeking and footing cost of surgical interventions.
Sustainable surgical resource initiative for Haiti: the SSRI-Haiti project
2023, Global Health ActionPosterior hemivertebra resection and short-segment fusion with lateral mass screws in congenital scoliosis: a novel strategy for the resource-limited setting
2021, Journal of Orthopaedic Surgery and Research