Abstract
There is a growing tendency for medicine to be used not to prevent or heal illnesses, but to fulfil individual personal wishes such as wishes for enhanced work performance, better social skills, children with specific characteristics, stress relief, a certain appearance or a better sex life. While recognizing that the subject of wish-fulfilling medicine may vary greatly and that it may employ very different techniques, this article argues that wish-fulfilling medicine can be described as a cohesive phenomenon with distinctive features. Following a few examples of well established wish-fulfilling medical practices and a brief definition of the phenomenon, both theoretical aspects and ethical implications of such practices are discussed and the question is raised how wish-fulfilling medicine should be evaluated from an ethical point of view. It is concluded that modern medicine is currently ill equipped to provide reasons why wish-fulfilling medicine should be banned or discouraged. The phenomenon of wish-fulfilling medicine serves as a prime example of the vagueness of the descriptive and the lack of decisive orientation of the normative categories employed in modern medicine.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Allen, D.B., Fost, N.C.: 1990, ‹Growth Hormone Therapy for Short Stuture: Panacea or Pandora’s Box?’, Journal of Pediatrics 117, 16–21
Austin, S.E.: 2001, Medical Justice. A Guide to Fair Provision. New York: Peter Lang Press
Birnbacher, D.: 2006, Natürlichkeit (Naturalness). Berlin/New York: De Gruyter. (German)
Boorse, C.: 1975, ‹On the Distinction Between Disease and Illness’, Philosophy and Public Affairs 5, 46–68
Boorse, C.: 1977, ‹Health as a Theoretical Concept’, Philosophy of Science 44, 542–573
Boorse, C.: 1997, ‹A Rebuttal on Health’. In J. Humber, & K. Almeder (eds.), What Is Disease? Totowa New Jersey: Humana Press, pp. 1–134
Bostrom, N.: 2005, ‹In Defense of Posthuman Dignity’, Bioethics 19(3), 202–214
Brülde, B.: 2001, ‹The Goals of Medicine. Towards a Unified Theory’, Health Care Analysis 9(1), 1–13
Buchanan, A.E., Brock, D.W., Daniels, N., Wikler, D.: 2000, From Chance to Choice. Genetics and Justice. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
Callahan, D.: 1998, False Hopes. Why America’s Quest for Perfect Health is a Recipe for Failure. New Brunswick New Jersey: Rutgers University Press
Caplan, A.L.: 2006, ‹Commentary: Is ‹Peter Pan’ Treatment Right? Debate Over Stunting a Disabled Child’s Growth Pits Comfort Against Ethics’. http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/16472931/ (28.06.2007)
Caplan, A.L.: 2004, ‹The “Unnaturalness” of Aging – Give Me Reason to Live!’. In A.L. Caplan, J.J. McCartney, D.A. Sisti (eds.), Health, Disease and Illness. Concepts in Medicine, Washington: Georgetown University Press, pp. 117–127
Caplan, A.L., McCartney, J.J., & Sisti D.A. (eds.): 2004, Health, Disease and Illness. Concepts in Medicine. Washington: Georgetown University Press
Clouser, K.D., Culver, C.M., Gert, B.: 1981, ‹Malady: A New Treatment of Disease’, Hastings Center Report 11(3), 29–37
Daniels, N.: 2000, ‹Normal Functioning and the Treatment-Enhancement Distinction’, Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics 9, 309–322
Davis, K.: 1995, Reshaping the Female Body: The Dilemma of Cosmetic Surgery. New York: Routledge
DeGrazia D.: 2006, ‹Moral Status, Human Identity, and Early Embryos: A Critique of the President’s Approach’, The Journal of Law, Medicine & Ethics 34(1), 49–57
DeGrazia D.: 2000, ‹Prozac, Enhancement and Self-Creation’, Hastings Center Report 30(2), 34–40
Emanuel, E.J.: 1991, The Ends of Human Life. Medical Ethics in a Liberal Polity. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press
Emanuel, E.J., Emanuel, L.L.: 1992, ‹Four Models of the Physician-Patient-Relationship’, Journal of the American Medical Association 267(16), 2221–2226
Emanuel, E.J. et al.: 2000, ‹Understanding Economic and Other Burdens of Terminal Disease: The Experience of Patients and Their Caregivers’, Annals of Internal Medicine 132, 451–459
Engelhardt H.T. Jr.: 1984, ‹Clinical Problems and the Concept of Disease’. In L. Nordenfelt, & B.I.B. Lindahl (eds.), Health, Disease and Causal Explanation in Medicine, Dordrecht: Kluwer, pp. 27–41
Engelhardt H.T. Jr.: 1986, ‹Clinical Complaints and the Ens Morbi’, Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 11(3), 207–214
Engelhardt H.T. Jr.: 1990, ‹Human Nature Technologically Revisited’, Social Philosophy and Policy 8(1), 180–191
Engelhardt Jr., H.T.: 19962, The Foundations of Bioethics. Oxford/New York: Oxford University Press
Engelhardt H.T. Jr.: 2002, Germ-Line Engineering: the Moral Challenges’, American Journal of Medical Genetics 108(2), 169–175
Faden, R.R., Beauchamp, T.L.: 1986, The History and Theory of Informed Consent. Oxford/New York: Oxford University Press
Feinberg, J.: 1986, The Moral Limits of the Criminal Law. Vol III: Harm to Self. Oxford/New York: Oxford University Press.
Fleischhauer, K., Hermeren, G.: 2006, Goals of Medicine in the Course of History and Today. Stockholm: Kungl. Vitterhets Historie
Fukuyama, F.: 2000, Our Posthuman Future. Consequence of the Biotechnology Revolution. Picador
German National Ethics Council: 2003, Genetic Diagnosis Before and During Pregnancy. http://www.ethikrat.org/ (29.06.2007).
Gilman, L.S.: 2001, Making the Body Beautiful. A Cultural History of Aesthetic Surgery. Princeton New Jersey: Princeton University Press
Gordijn, B.: 2006, Medical Utopias. Ethical Reflections About Emerging Medical Technologies. Leuven: Peeters Publishers
Habermas, J.: 20054, The Future of Human Nature (Die Zukunft der menschlichen Natur. Auf dem Weg zu einer liberalen Eugenik?). Frankfurt a.M.: Suhrkamp
Haiken, E.: 1997, Venus Envy – A History of Cosmetic Surgery. Baltimore: The John Hopkins University Press
Halper, T.: 2003, Positive Rights in a Republic of Talk. A Survey and a Critique. Dordrecht: Kluwer Academic Publishers
Hanson, M.J., & Callahan, D. (eds.): 1999, The Goals of Medicine: The Forgotten Issues in Health Care Reform. Washington: Georgetown University Press
Hastings Center Report: 1996, ‹The Goals of Medicine. Setting New Priorities’. The Hastings Center Report 26(6), special issue pp. S1–S27
Hucklenbroich, P.: 2007, ,Krankheit – Begriffserklärung und Grundlage einer Krankheitstheorie‹, (Illness – Concepts and Foundations of a Theorie of Illness) Erwägen Wissen Ethik 18(1), 77–90 (German)
Humber, J., & Almeder, K. (eds.): 1997, What Is Disease?. Totowa, New Jersey: Humana Press
Keefe, R., & Smith, P. (eds.): 1999, Vagueness: A Reader. Cambridge, Mass./London: The MIT Press
Kettner, M.: 2006, ,,,Wunscherfüllende Medizin“ – Assistenz zum besseren Leben?',(Wish-fulfilling medicine – assistance for a better life?), GGW 6(2), 7–16 (German)
Little, M.O.: 1998, ‹Cosmetic Surgery, Suspect Norms, and the Ethics of Complicity’. In Parens, E (ed.) Enhancing Human Traits. Ethical and Social Implications, Washington: Georgetown University Press, pp. 162–175
Maio, G.: 2007, ‹Medizin im Umbruch. Ethisch-anthropologische Grundfragen zu den Paradigmen der modernen Medizin’. (Medicine in upheaval. Ethical and anthropological questions regarding the paradigms of modern medicine), Zeitschrift für medizinische Ethik 53(3), 229–254 (German)
Meier D.E., et al.: 1998, ‹A National Survey of Physician Assisted Suicide and Euthanasia in the United States’, New England Journal of Medicine 338, 1193–1201
Nordenfelt, L.: 1995, On the Nature of Health: An Action-Theoretic Approach. Dordrecht: D. Reidel Publishing
Nordenfelt, L.: 1997, Talking About Health. Amsterdam: Rodopi
Nordenfelt, L.: 1998, ‹On Medicine and Other Means of Health Enhancement – Toward a Conceptual Framework’, Medicine, Health Care and Philosophy 1, 5–12
Nordenfelt, L.: 2001, ‹On the goals of medicine, health enhancement and social welfare’, Health Care Analysis 9(1), 15–23
Parens, E. (ed.): 1998, Enhancing Human Traits. Ethical and Social Implications. Washington: Georgetown University Press
Pellegrino, E.D.: 1999, ‹The Goals and Ends of Medicine – How are They to be Defined?’ In: M.J. Hanson, D. Callahan (eds.), The Goals of Medicine: The Forgotten Issues in Health Care Reform, Washington: Georgetown University Press, pp. 55–68
Pellegrino, E.D., Thomasma, D.C.: 1981, A Philosophical Basis of Medical Practice: Toward a Philosophy of and Ethic of the Healing Professions. Oxford/New York: Oxford University Press
Schöne-Seifert, B.: 2005, ‹Von der Medizin zur Humantechnologie? Ärztliches Handeln zwischen medizinischer Indikation und Patientenwunsch’ (From medicine to ,,,Humantechnologie”. Doctors’ actions between medical indication and patient wishes.). In W. van den Daele (ed.), Biopolitik, Wiesbaden: VS Verlag für Sozialwissenschaften, pp. 179–199 (German)
The President’s Council on Bioethics: 2003, Beyond Therapy. Biotechnology and the Pursuit of Happiness. Washington: Dana Press
Various Authors: 2005, ‹Semantic Cell Transplantation’, The American Journal of Bioethics 6(5)
Wiesing, U.: 2006, ‹Die ästhetische Chirurgie. Eine Skizze der ethischen Probleme’ (Aesthetical surgery. An outline of the ethical problems), Zeitschrift für medizinische Ethik 52(2), 139–154 (German)
Wolf, N.: 1991, The Beauty Myth. New York: William Morrow
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Buyx, A.M. Be careful what you wish for? Theoretical and ethical aspects of wish-fulfilling medicine. Med Health Care Philos 11, 133–143 (2008). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11019-007-9111-1
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11019-007-9111-1