Abstract
A lot of interest has been generated by the possibility of deriving gametes from embryonic stem cells and bone marrow stem cells. These stem cell derived gametes may become useful for research and for the treatment of infertility. In this article we consider prospectively the ethical issues that will arise if stem cell derived gametes are used in the clinic, making a distinction between concerns that only apply to embryonic stem cell derived gametes and concerns that are also relevant for gametes derived from adult stem cells. At present, it appears preferable to use non-embryonic stem cells for the derivation of gametes. Adult stem cell derived gametes do not present any problems with regard to the moral status of the human embryo, bypass the safety risks linked to SCNT and do not present any ambiguity or novel problems with regard to informed consent, psychological consequences for the child or genetic parenthood. A remaining ethical concern, however, regards the safety of the procedure in terms of the welfare of the resulting children. This should spark a thorough reflection on how far one must go to accommodate a person’s wish to have a genetically related child.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Baetens, P., Devroey, P., Camus, M., Van Steirteghem, A., & Ponjaert-Kristoffersen, I. (2000). Counselling couples and donors for oocyte donation: The decision to use either known or anonymous oocytes. Human Reproduction, 15, 476–484.
Bonduelle, M. L. (2003). ICSI-related risk for the children. PhD. Thesis, Vrije Universiteit Brussel, Brussels.
Devolder, K. (2005). Creating and sacrificing embryos for stem cells. Journal of Medical Ethics, 31, 366–370.
Drusenheimer, N., Wulf, G., Nolte, J., et al. (2007). Putative human male germ cells from bone marrow stem cells. Society of Reproduction and Fertility supplement, 63, 69–76.
ESHRE Task Force on Ethics and Law. (2007). The welfare of the child in medically assisted reproduction. Human Reproduction, 22, 2585–2588.
Fukuyama, F., & Furger, F. (2006). Beyond bioethics: A proposal for modernizing the regulation of human biotechnologies. Washington, D.C.: Paul H. Nitze School of Advanced International Studies.
Hinxton Group. (2008). Consensus statement: Science, ethics and policy challenges of pluripotent stem cell-derived gametes. April 11, 2008. http://www.hinxtongroup.org/.
Holden, C. (2008). A seismic shift for stem cell research. Science, 319, 560–563.
Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority, Ethics and Law Committee. (2006). In vitro derived gametes. Report of the Meeting of 16th January 2006.
Leese, H. J., & Whittall, H. (2001). Regulation of the transition from research to clinical practice in human assisted conception. Human Fertility, 4, 172–176.
Mertes, H., & Pennings, G. (2008). Embryonic stem cell-derived gametes and genetic parenthood: A problematic relationship. Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics, 17, 7–14.
Nagy, Z. P., & Chang, C.-C. (2007). Artificial gametes. Theriogenology, 67, 99–104.
Nayernia, K., Nolte, J., Michelmann, H. W., et al. (2006). In vitro-differentiated embryonic stem cells give rise to male gametes that can generate offspring mice. Developmental Cell, 11, 125–132.
Nayernia, K., et al. (2007). From stem cells to germ cells and from germ cells to stem cells. Iranian Journal of Reproductive Medicine, 5, 41–44.
Newson, A. J., & Smajdor, A. C. (2005). Artificial gametes: New paths to parenthood? Journal of Medical Ethics, 31, 184–186.
Pennings, G. (1999). Measuring the welfare of the child: In search of the appropriate evaluation criterion. Human Reproduction, 14, 146–150.
Pennings, G. (2000). Multiple pregnancies: A test case for the moral status of medically assisted reproduction. Human Reproduction, 15, 2466–2469.
Pilcher, H. (2006). The egg and sperm race. New Scientist, October 21 2006, 52–54.
Practice Committee of the Society for Assisted Reproductive Technology, & The Practice Committee of the American Society for Reproductive Medicine. (2007). Essential elements of informed consent for elective oocyte cryopreservation: A Practice Committee opinion. Fertility and Sterility, 88, 1495–1496.
Robertson, J. (1994). Children of choice. Princeton, New Jersey: Princeton University Press.
Smajdor, A. (2008). Artificial gametes: The end of infertility? Bionews 446, February 26, 2008. http://www.bionews.org.uk/commentary.lasso?storyid=3740.
Takahashi, K., & Yamanaka, S. (2006). Induction of pluripotent stem cells from adult human fibroblasts by defined factors. Cell, 131, 861–872.
Testa, G., & Harris, J. (2005). Ethics and synthetic gametes. Bioethics, 19, 146–166.
West, J. A., & Daley, G. Q. (2004). In vitro gametogenesis from embryonic stem cells. Current Opinion in Cell Biology, 16, 688–692.
Whittaker, P. (2007). Stem cells to gametes: How far should we go? Human Fertility, 10, 1–5.
Zaninovic, N., et al. (2007). Genetic modification of preimplantation embryos and embryonic stem cells (ESC) by recombinant vectors: Efficient and stable method for creating transgenic embryos and ESC. Fertility and Sterility, 88(Suppl. 1), S310.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Mertes, H., Pennings, G. Ethical Aspects of the Use of Stem Cell Derived Gametes for Reproduction. Health Care Anal 18, 267–278 (2010). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10728-009-0136-x
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10728-009-0136-x