Comparison of ethical issues raised by genomic passports and immunity passports
Ethical issue | Immunity passport | Genomic passport |
Incentivise infection | Yes (for natural immunity) | No |
Privacy risk | Minimal personal information collected | Potentially substantial personal information collected |
Undermine solidarity | Possible | Possible |
Exacerbate inequalities | Possible | Likely if based on biased data |
Fairness (luck egalitarianism) | No unique concerns | Raises unique concerns |