Table 2

Ethical principles of prophylaxis relevant to Left Of Bang Interventions in Trauma (from Sugarman and Mayer27 and WHO/UNAIDS28)

Well-being/UtilityThe benefits of the prophylaxis must outweigh the harms
SafetyApart from direct side effects, consideration must be given to the potential risks of the prophylaxis, for example, consequences of imperfect adherence.
Parameters of useIf data on safe and effective use are limited, prophylaxis must only be used within the limits of these data, that is, generalisability to different populations or uses must not be assumed.
Risk behavioursSteps must be taken to educate recipients about avoidance of risk compensation and to monitor changes in risk-related behaviour.
StigmaConsideration must be given to how others may perceive those receiving prophylaxis, for example, difficulties obtaining insurance.
DiversionIn resource-poor settings, there is a possibility that drugs that can be used to treat extant conditions are diverted to prevent the same or other conditions.
Equity/JusticeThere should be a fair distribution of risks and benefits among the relevant population.
AccessProphylaxis must be acceptable to the population at risk. This includes both the formulation of the treatment and the system of provision.
Competing prioritiesConsideration must be given to how to distribute risks and benefits fairly. What ‘fairness’ means may change over time and depends on available resources, risk environment and societal norms.