Table 1

Two cases

Retrospective MacCAT scores,1 assessed by researcher (AR) at time of research interview at patients home address
According to patient him/herself, retrospectivelyAccording to psychiatristUnderstandingAppreciationReasoningChoiceTotalBased on retrospective MacCAT scores plus clinical judgementAccording to emotions approach (Charland)According to values approach (Tan et al)According to practical wisdom approach
 Hospital admission646218+++
 Discontinuation CBT++/−646218+++
 To stop CBT and medication++/−533213+/−++
  • +, Competent; −, not competent; +/−, more or less competent; CBT, cognitive behavioural therapy.