Table 1

Summary of applied ethical precepts for the Rwandan context

PreceptApplied indicators
Benefit▸ Save more lives
▸ Share benefit: contribute financially to family and community
▸ Advance local medical professionals’ expertise
▸ Develop international professional network
▸ Enhance nation's reputation for medical expertise and leadership in East African region
▸ Cause patients and families to smile
Harm▸ Poor outcomes, including death
▸ Demand for surgery exceeds available resources
▸ Inadequate access to postoperative services
▸ Divert limited operating-room time to RHD surgery
▸ Limited opportunities for postoperative jobs, education
▸ Prescribed medications incompatible with traditional diet
Justice▸ Selection criteria exclude certain groups
▸ Consider patient productivity in selection process
▸ Assist with copay
▸ Inability to address background injustices
Transparency▸ Openly disclose selection criteria
▸ Include multiple stakeholders in designating criteria for RHD surgery
Respect▸ Refer patients who are not chosen
▸ Follow-up and console patients not selected
▸ Honour family and community roles in patient-directed choice of treatment
▸ Respect choices of women to prioritise childbearing over longevity
  • RHD, rheumatic heart disease.