Table 4

A display of the response pattern among physicians who classified the withdrawal of life-sustaining treatment as a defensible act

Case 1Case 2Case 3
77-year-old woman36-year-old man34-year-old man
DialysisDialysisVentilator
A defensible actMale90 (87–93)80 (76–84)67 (62–72)
Female85 (80–90)64 (57–71)63 (56–70)
<54 years92 (89–95)77 (72–82)64 (59–69)
>53 years85 (81–89)72 (67–77)67 (62–72)
Internal medicine89 (83–95)73 (65–81)67 (58–76)
Surgery94 (90–98)82 (75–89)64 (55–73)
Anaesthesiology95 (91–99)86 (80–92)71 (63–79)
Subspeciality internal medicine93 (88–98)79 (71–87)72 (63–81)
General practice80 (72–88)65 (55–75)56 (46–66)
Psychiatry76 (68–84)61 (52–70)61 (52–70)
  • The break between older/younger physicians is set at 53 years (mean age). The results are presented as proportions with a 95% CI.