TY - JOUR T1 - Directed altruistic living donation: what is wrong with the beauty contest? JF - Journal of Medical Ethics JO - J Med Ethics SP - 875 LP - 879 DO - 10.1136/medethics-2014-102230 VL - 41 IS - 11 AU - Greg Moorlock Y1 - 2015/11/01 UR - http://jme.bmj.com/content/41/11/875.abstract N2 - This paper explores the specific criticism of directed altruistic living organ donation that it creates a ‘beauty contest’ between potential recipients of organs. The notion of the beauty contest in transplantation was recently used by Neidich et al who stated that ‘[a]ltruism should be the guiding motivation for all donations, and when it [is], there is no place for a beauty contest’. I examine this beauty contest objection from two perspectives. First, I argue that, when considered against the behaviour of donors, this objection cannot be consistently raised without also objecting to other common aspects of organ donation. I then explore the beauty contest objection from the perspective of recipients, and argue that if the beauty contest is objectionable, it is because of a tension between recipient behaviour and the altruism that supposedly underpins the donation system. I conclude by briefly questioning the importance of this tension in light of the organ shortage. ER -