%0 Journal Article %A Michael H Kottow %T A reply to Professor Seedhouse. %D 1999 %R 10.1136/jme.25.4.349 %J Journal of Medical Ethics %P 349-350 %V 25 %N 4 %X This brief reply gives a few references and clarifies some points in order to emphasize that a number of Professor Seedhouse's assertions are debatable and that his criticism of slovenly scholarship and his unbridled ad hominem argumentation are out of place and easily refuted. %U https://jme.bmj.com/content/medethics/25/4/349.full.pdf