eLetters

498 e-Letters

  • A hierachy of access to information/ knowledge is unethical
    susanne stevens

    There is a hierarchy of means to access opinions and information published in journals. This is unethical in a democracy which uses citizens' information to contribute to debates- from which they are then excluded. This to some extent mirrors my position that it is unethical to with hold information from clients in therapy. It is taking advantage of vulnerability however it is dressed up but also creates a hierarchy of...

    Show More
  • Ethical Discrimination?
    susanne stevens

    A properly worded consent form must make risks transparent but if the person has not even been asked to participate, discrimination is too easily slipping in. Even giving the reason as duty of care can be mis/used to eliminate some people - but their participation may be valuable as well as ethical. There can be an unconscious bias to avoid difficulties for researchers but discrimination will miss opportunities for the...

    Show More
  • Proposed FGM 'compromise' illuminates medical complicity with non-therapeutic fee-paying surgery on infants
    Susan Bewley

    The JME's peer reviewers failed to press the clinical issues before publication of this flawed paper(1). The unoriginal idea of a 'ritual nick' performed by health professionals in a harm limitation approach to female genital mutilation (FGM) was proposed by the American Academy of Pediatrics back in 2010(2), who rapidly replaced their statement(3) in the face of worldwide condemnation(4) by the World Health Organisation...

    Show More
  • Medical aid in dying in Quebec and Canada: facts matter
    Michele Marchand

    As an active participant in the debate that took place in the province of Quebec concerning medical aid in dying (MAID), I would like to take the liberty of commenting on an article by Udo Shuklenk published recently in your journal: "Canada on course to introduce permissive assisted dying regime". In my view, some of the factual information given in this text needs more precision.

    First of all, the chronology...

    Show More
  • Kissing Paediatric Patients
    P K Coulson-Smith

    From the beginnings of our lives as doctors, we are taught about professionalism. Professionalism encourages and enables doctors to maintain focus on the patient's needs and treatment.

    Kissing a child oversteps the boundary of professionalism. Such contact shifts thinking from the patient to the professional and meets the professional's emotional needs rather than the patient's.

    Physical contact with p...

    Show More
  • Prostitution is not justified by sexual "needs": an alternative to full legalisation
    Nathan Hodson

    Earp and Moen demonstrate the absence of a relevant difference between the use of prostitutes by disabled people and by shy, ugly, libidinous, able-bodied people, and the impossibility of circumscribing the latter[1]. This is incorporated into a case for the full legalisation of prostitution based on: (a) the absence of a justification for its prohibition; and (b) the "needs" it meets. We posit that (b) misrepresents pro...

    Show More
  • The Rights of Terrible People
    susanne stevens

    There are surely situations where responses of disgust and other reactions to extreme violence must be respected. How much they effect the justice system as well as the medical professionals' ability to act strictly according to laws and ethical guidelines is probably difficult to investigate. The case of Peter Sutcliffe - a violent mass murderer in UK is not quite the same scenario as the article describes but it is...

    Show More
  • Censorship of media and scholarly debates and avoiding collateral damage to public confidence in organ donation
    Michael Potts

    We read with great interest Daoust and Racine's contribution to the ongoing debate about brain death and its ethical and medical implications [1]. The authors argue that little is known about how the public understands the concept of death determined by neurological criteria (DNC). They set out to trace common sources of public confusion about DNC and seek to "better define the relationship between expert and lay views...

    Show More

Pages