Article Text
Abstract
Disease radically changes the life of many people and satisfies formal criteria for being a transformative experience. According to the influential philosophy of Paul, transformative experiences undermine traditional criteria for rational decision-making. Thus, the transformative experience of disease can challenge basic principles and rules in medical ethics, such as patient autonomy and informed consent. This article applies Paul’s theory of transformative experience and its expansion by Carel and Kidd to investigate the implications for medical ethics. It leads to the very uncomfortable conclusion that disease involves transformative experiences in ways that can reduce people’s rational decision-making ability and undermine the basic principle of respect for autonomy and the moral rule of informed consent. While such cases are limited, they are crucial for medical ethics and health policy and deserve more attention and further scrutiny.
- autonomy
- personal autonomy
- informed consent
- ethics
Data availability statement
All data relevant to the study are included in the article. All data are available in the manuscript.
Statistics from Altmetric.com
Read the full text or download the PDF:
Other content recommended for you
- Medical ethics for children: applying the four principles to paediatrics
- Substituted decision making and the dispositional choice account
- In defence of personal autonomy
- No going back? Reversibility and why it matters for deep brain stimulation
- Ethics needs principles—four can encompass the rest—and respect for autonomy should be “first among equals”
- Authenticity and autonomy in deep-brain stimulation
- Disfigured anatomies and imperfect analogies: body integrity identity disorder and the supposed right to self-demanded amputation of healthy body parts
- Practising what we preach: clinical ethicists’ professional perspectives and personal use of advance directives
- First among equals? Adaptive preferences and the limits of autonomy in medical ethics
- Consent for anaesthesia