Article Text
Abstract
Sara Kolmes has argued that the human ‘handlers’ of emotional support animals (ESAs) should have the sorts of body-like rights to those animals that people with prosthetics have to their prosthetics. In support of this conclusion, she argues that ESAs both function and feel like prosthetics, and that the disanalogies between ESAs and prosthetics are irrelevant to whether humans can have body-like rights to their ESAs. In response, we argue that Ms Kolmes has failed to show that ESAs are body-like in the ways that paradigmatic prostheses are and that, even if they were, these similarities would be outweighed by a crucial dissimilarity that she underestimates.
- disability
- philosophical ethics
- applied and professional ethics
Statistics from Altmetric.com
Footnotes
Contributors JdT and DB contributed equally to this paper.
Funding The authors have not declared a specific grant for this research from any funding agency in the public, commercial or not-for-profit sectors.
Competing interests None declared.
Provenance and peer review Not commissioned; externally peer reviewed.
Linked Articles
Read the full text or download the PDF:
Other content recommended for you
- Are emotional support animals prosthetics or pets? Body-like rights to emotional support animals
- When pigs fly: emotional support animals, service dogs and the politics of legitimacy across species boundaries
- Words
- Being well together? Promoting health and well-being through more than human collaboration and companionship
- Parroting patriots: interspecies trauma and becoming-well-together
- Prosthesis and the engineered imagination: reading augmentation and disability across cultural theory, representation and product design
- Virtual volunteers: the importance of restructuring medical volunteering during the COVID-19 pandemic
- Clinical management of quadriplegia in low and middle-income countries: a patient’s road to physiotherapy, prostheses and rehabilitation
- The Paralympic effect on amputees’ legal claims for prosthetics
- ‘Limbitless Solutions’: the Prosthetic Arm, Iron Man and the Science Fiction of Technoscience