Article Text
Abstract
It has traditionally been assumed that organ donation must be altruistic, though the necessity of altruistic motivations has recently been questioned. Few, however, have questioned whether altruism is always a good motive. This paper considers the possibility that excessive altruism, or self-abnegation, may be intrinsically bad. How this may be so is illustrated with reference to Tom Hurka’s account of the value of attitudes, which suggests that disproportionate love of one’s own good—either excessive or deficient—is intrinsically bad. Whether or not we accept the details of this account, recognising that altruistic motivations may be intrinsically bad has important implications for organ procurement. One possible response is to say that we should take further measures to ensure that donors have good motives—that they are altruistic is no longer enough. An alternative is to say that, since altruistic donation need not be intrinsically good, we have less reason to object to other motivations.
- donation/procurement of organs/tissues
- philosophical ethics
Statistics from Altmetric.com
Footnotes
Twitter Please follow Ben Saunders @DrBenSaunders
Funding The author has not declared a specific grant for this research from any funding agency in the public, commercial or not-for-profit sectors.
Competing interests None declared.
Patient consent Not required.
Provenance and peer review Not commissioned; externally peer reviewed.
Presented at Earlier versions of this paper were presented to the Philosophy Department, University of Stirling (February 2013) and the Health Ethics And Law group, University of Southampton (October 2015).
Read the full text or download the PDF:
Other content recommended for you
- Demanding pure motives for donation: the moral acceptability of blood donations by haemochromatosis patients
- Self-interest, self-abnegation and self-esteem: towards a new moral economy of non-directed kidney donation
- “Living apart together”: moral frictions between two coexisting organ transplantation schemes
- Imposing options on people in poverty: the harm of a live donor organ market
- Altruism in organ donation: an unnecessary requirement?
- Directed altruistic living donation: what is wrong with the beauty contest?
- Opt-out organ donation without presumptions
- The social rationale of the gift relationship
- The search for organs: halachic perspectives on altruistic giving and the selling of organs
- A virtue ethics approach to moral dilemmas in medicine