Article Text
Abstract
I argue that Schmidt et al, while correctly diagnosing the serious racial inequity in current ventilator rationing procedures, misidentify a corresponding racial inequity issue in alternative ‘unweighted lottery’ procedures. Unweighted lottery procedures do not ‘compound’ (in the relevant sense) prior structural injustices. However, Schmidt et al do gesture towards a real problem with unweighted lotteries that previous advocates of lottery-based allocation procedures, myself included, have previously overlooked. On the basis that there are independent reasons to prefer lottery-based allocation of scarce lifesaving healthcare resources, I develop this idea, arguing that unweighted lottery procedures fail to satisfy healthcare providers’ duty to prevent unjust population-level health outcomes, and thus that lotteries weighted in favour of Black individuals (and others who experience serious health injustice) are to be preferred.
- allocation of health care resources
- COVID-19
- distributive justice
- minorities
- Public Health Ethics
Statistics from Altmetric.com
Footnotes
Contributors AJMT is the sole author.
Funding The authors have not declared a specific grant for this research from any funding agency in the public, commercial or not-for-profit sectors.
Competing interests None declared.
Provenance and peer review Not commissioned; externally peer reviewed.
Linked Articles
Read the full text or download the PDF:
Other content recommended for you
- Rationing, racism and justice: advancing the debate around ‘colourblind’ COVID-19 ventilator allocation
- Sequential organ failure assessment, ventilator rationing and evolving triage guidance: new evidence underlines the need to recognise and revise, unjust allocation frameworks
- Centring race, deprivation, and disease severity in healthcare priority setting
- The draw of the few: the challenge of crisis guidelines for extremely scarce resources
- Discoid lupus erythematosus skin lesion distribution and characteristics in Black patients: a retrospective cohort study
- Longitudinal visual field variability and the ability to detect glaucoma progression in black and white individuals
- Dynapaenic obesity and its association with health outcomes in older adult populations: protocol for a systematic review
- Triage of critical care resources in COVID-19: a stronger role for justice
- What is common and what is different: recommendations from European scientific societies for triage in the first outbreak of COVID-19
- Allocation of scarce resources during the COVID-19 pandemic: a Jewish ethical perspective