Article Text
Statistics from Altmetric.com
Russell Powell and Eric Scarffe1 are pluralists about disease. They offer their thickly normative account to meet the needs of doctors, but they allow that a different concept of disease might work better for zoologists.
In this commentary, I grant that Powell and Scarffe’s thickly normative evaluation of biological dysfunction works well in many medicinal contexts. Powell and Scarffe respond effectively to eliminativists—we should retain the concept of disease. But the paper’s pluralism and focus on the specific needs of institutions should permit us to eliminate the notion of disease from domains for which the historical grounding of their selected effects account of function are contrary to therapeutic goals. One such domain is mental health. I found Powell and Scarffe’s rejection of Boorse’s dispositional account of biological function persuasive—the selected effects account of function is a superior fit for biologists’ use of the term. But the historical nature of this concept is, at best, a distraction from the task of morally evaluating the many ways in which …
Footnotes
Contributors This is all author’s own work.
Competing interests None declared.
Provenance and peer review Commissioned; internally peer reviewed.
Patient consent for publication Not required.
Request Permissions
If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.
Copyright information:
Linked Articles
Read the full text or download the PDF:
Other content recommended for you
- ‘ Rethinking “ Disease ”: a fresh diagnosis and a new philosophical treatment ’
- Does the harm component of the harmful dysfunction analysis need rethinking?: Reply to Powell and Scarffe
- The definition of mental disorder: evolving but dysfunctional
- Response to commentaries on Powell / Scarffe feature article
- Donald West: criminologist who served as president of the Society for Psychical Research and whose work contributed to the decriminalisation of homosexuality
- Treatment of homosexuality during apartheid
- High prevalence of HIV among men who have sex with men in Zhejiang, China: a respondent - driven sampling survey
- Does chaos theory have major implications for philosophy of medicine
- Short term estimates of adult HIV incidence by mode of transmission: Kenya and Thailand as examples
- Of prostitutes and homosexuals: AIDS from 1981 to 1990