Article Text
Abstract
As the prevalence of dementia increases across the Western world, there is a growing interest in advance care planning, by which patients may make decisions on behalf of their future selves. Under which ethical principles is this practice justified? I assess the justification for advance care planning put forward by the philosopher Ronald Dworkin, which he rationalises through an integrity-based conception of autonomy. I suggest his judgement is misguided by arguing in favour of two claims. First, that patients with dementia qualify for some right to contemporary autonomy conceptualised under the ‘sense of liberty’ it provides. Second, that respecting precedent autonomy, such as an advance care plan, is not essential to Dworkin’s integrity-based account of autonomy. Together, my claims problematise the practice of using advance decisions in the context of dementia.
- autonomy
- dementia
- elderly and terminally ill
- living wills/advance directives
- psychiatry
Statistics from Altmetric.com
Read the full text or download the PDF:
Other content recommended for you
- Euthanasia in persons with advanced dementia: a dignity-enhancing care approach
- An introduction to advance care planning in practice
- Three arguments against prescription requirements
- Formal and effective autonomy in healthcare
- Socially and temporally extended end-of-life decision-making process for dementia patients
- Which moral barriers and facilitators do physicians encounter in advance care planning conversations about the end of life of persons with dementia? A meta-review of systematic reviews and primary studies
- Practising what we preach: clinical ethicists’ professional perspectives and personal use of advance directives
- Adverse consequences of article 12 of the UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities for persons with mental disabilities and an alternative way forward
- Is respect for autonomy defensible?
- Management of patients with an advance decision and suicidal behaviour: a systematic review