Recent developments in biotechnology allow for the generation of increasingly complex products out of human tissues, for example, human stem cell lines, synthetic embryo-like structures and organoids. These developments are coupled with growing commercial interests. Although commercialisation can spark the scientific and clinical promises, profit-making out of human tissues is ethically contentious and known to raise public concern. The traditional bioethical frames of gift versus market are inapt to capture the resulting practical and ethical complexities. Therefore, we propose an alternative approach to identify, evaluate and deal with the ethical challenges that are raised by the increasing commercialisation of the exchange of sophisticated human tissue products. We use organoid technology, a cutting-edge stem cell technology that enables the cultivation of ‘mini-organs’ in a dish, as an example. First, we examine the moral value of organoids and recognise them as hybrids that relate to persons and their bodies as well as to technologies and markets in ambiguous ways. Second, we show that commercialisation of organoids is legitimised by a detachment of the instrumental and commercial value of organoids from their associations with persons and their bodies. This detachment is enacted in steps of disentanglement, among which consent and commodification. Third, we contend that far-reaching disentanglement is ethically challenging: (1) Societal interests could be put under pressure, because the rationale for commercialising organoid technology, that is, to stimulate biomedical innovation for the good of society, may not be fulfilled; (2) The interests of donors are made subordinate to those of third parties and the relational moral value of organoids may be insufficiently recognised. Fourth, we propose a ‘consent for governance’ model that contributes to responsible innovation and clinical translation in this exciting field.
- research ethics
- stem cell research
- donation/procurement of organs/tissues
- social control of science/technology
Statistics from Altmetric.com
If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.
Contributors SNB drafted the first manuscript. SNB, JJMvD and ALB made substantial contribution to the manuscript and revised it critically. All authors have read and approved the final manuscript.
Funding We gratefully acknowledge financial support by the associate professor’s stimulation grant, a personal grant awarded to ALB by the UMC Utrecht, The Netherlands.
Competing interests None declared.
Patient consent Not required.
Provenance and peer review Not commissioned; externally peer reviewed.
Read the full text or download the PDF:
Other content recommended for you
- Organoids in gastrointestinal diseases: from experimental models to clinical translation
- Ex vivo culture of the intestinal epithelium: strategies and applications
- Cerebral organoids: ethical issues and consciousness assessment
- Liver organoids: from basic research to therapeutic applications
- Building pancreatic organoids to aid drug development
- A novel human gastric primary cell culture system for modelling Helicobacter pylori infection in vitro
- Patient-derived cellular models of primary ciliopathies
- Lessons from Frankenstein 200 years on: brain organoids, chimaeras and other ‘monsters’
- Location-specific cell identity rather than exposure to GI microbiota defines many innate immune signalling cascades in the gut epithelium
- DNA methylation defines regional identity of human intestinal epithelial organoids and undergoes dynamic changes during development