Article Text
Abstract
In her paper ‘Cosmetic surgery and conscientious objection’, Minerva rightly identifies cosmetic surgery as an interesting test case for the question of conscientious objection in medicine. Her treatment of this important subject, however, seems problematic. It is argued that Minerva's suggestion that a doctor has a prima facie duty to satisfy patient preferences even against his better clinical judgment, which we call Patient Preference Absolutism, must be regarded with scepticism. This is because (1) it overlooks an important distinction regarding autonomy's meaning and place in clinical practice, and (2) it makes obsolete the important concepts of expert clinical judgment and beneficence. Finally, we discuss two ideas which emerge from consideration of cosmetic surgery in relation to conscientious objection. These are the possible analogy between clinical judgment and conscientious objection, and the possible role the goals of medicine can play in defining the scope of conscientious objection.
- Conscientious Objection
- Autonomy
- Capacity
Statistics from Altmetric.com
Read the full text or download the PDF:
Other content recommended for you
- The truth behind conscientious objection in medicine
- Toward accommodating physicians’ conscientious objections: an argument for public disclosure
- Some difficulties involved in locating the truth behind conscientious objection in medicine
- The need for feasible compromises on conscientious objection: response to Card
- The Market View on conscientious objection: overvalued
- Conscientious objection in medical students: a questionnaire survey
- In defence of medical tribunals and the reasonability standard for conscientious objection in medicine
- Why medical professionals have no moral claim to conscientious objection accommodation in liberal democracies
- Conscientious objection should not be equated with moral objection: a response to Ben-Moshe
- The truth behind conscientious objection in medicine: a reply to Clarke, Emmerich, Minerva and Saad