Article Text
Abstract
There is as yet no widely agreed-upon solution to the standard textbook problem whether actively shutting off a life-sustaining medical device, e.g. a respirator, and thus bringing about a patient's death amounts to active killing or just to an omission of further treatment. Apart from a range of astutely contrived case examples and respective particular solutions proposed in the literature, there seems to be no consensus on the normative principles such solutions should be grounded in, not even on the need for such principles beyond sheer intuition. The present paper attempts to develop a normative approach based on fundamental principles of law. From this perspective, what is decisive for the question of ‘killing or letting die’ in such cases is not that death ensues from a behaviour that is active and relevantly causative, but rather, whether or not the agent in performing the deadly act transgresses the boundaries of the domain of his or her sole normative authority, and thereby intervenes in the protected sphere of another. Unless he or she does so, their behaviour cannot be classified as active commission regardless of the amount of causal activity it may display and regardless of its potentially harmful consequences. This conception is spelled out in detail and tested in a range of case examples, as are several of its corollaries that deviate from standard type solutions.
- Ethics
Statistics from Altmetric.com
Request Permissions
If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.
Copyright information:
Linked Articles
- The concise argument
Read the full text or download the PDF:
Other content recommended for you
- The ethics of and the appropriate legislation concerning killing people and letting them die: a response to Merkel
- A stronger policy of organ retrieval from cadaveric donors: some ethical considerations
- Drowning among fishing communities on the Tanzanian shore of lake Victoria: a mixed - methods study to examine incidence, risk factors and socioeconomic impact
- Barriers to life jacket use among adult recreational boaters
- Informing policy on open water drowning prevention: an observational survey of life jacket use in Washington state
- Are life vests worn? A multiregional observational study of personal flotation device use in small boats
- The 1998 European Resuscitation Council guidelines for adult single rescuer basic life support
- Characteristics of drowning by different age groups
- The face of CPR
- Donald Liu