The European Clinical Trials Directive was issued in 2001 and aimed to simplify and harmonise the regulatory framework of clinical trials throughout Europe, thus stimulating European research. However, significant complexity and inconsistency remains due to disparate interpretation by EU member states. Critical care research has been particularly impacted due to variable and often restrictive consenting procedures for incapacitated subjects, with some countries requiring a court-appointed representative, while others recognise consent from family members and occasionally professional representatives. Furthermore, the absence of a waiver of consent threatened to put an end to emergency research in Europe and was met with varied responses. Approval procedures by ethics committees are equally inconsistent, particularly those relating to provision of a single opinion for multi-centre trials. Although evidence is somewhat mixed, this complexity as well as a general increase in administrative and financial burden following the Directive has been shown to cause a reduction in clinical trial activity in Europe, particularly academic trials.
We aim to clarify some of these inconsistent procedures, particularly those relating to informed consent of incapacitated subjects, as well as discussing some general weaknesses and possible improvements of the Directive ahead of its planned revision in 2011.
- informed consent
- interests of health personnel/institutions
- mentally ill and disabled persons
Statistics from Altmetric.com
If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.
This paper describes the success and limitations of the European directive on clinical trails in intensive care and emergency medicine 5 years after implementation.
Peter Andrews is Professor in the Department of Anaesthesia, Critical Care & Pain Medicine, University of Edinburgh & Consultant in Critical Care, Western General Hospital. He has been chief investigator (CI) of an MRC funded critical care RCT in the UK and is CI of a large Pan-European clinical trail that will eventually recruit patients throughout the world. Katy Robinson is a post-graduate student studying medicine at the University of Edinburgh. Katy successfully gained competitive funding to undertake a summer studentship with PA. This involved considerable literature searching, email and web based retrieval of information, including correspondence with the competent authorities in most European countries. This work was undertaken to provide information to support the EUROTHERM3235Trial (ISRCTN 34555414).
Guarantor. Peter JD Andrews.
Funding Other funders: European Society of Intensive Care Medicine.
Competing interests None.
Provenance and peer review Not commissioned; externally peer reviewed.
Read the full text or download the PDF:
Other content recommended for you
- Effect of European Clinical Trials Directive on academic drug trials in Denmark: retrospective study of applications to the Danish Medicines Agency 1993-2006
- Development in the number of clinical trial applications in Western Europe from 2007 to 2015: retrospective study of data from national competent authorities
- Impact of the Clinical Trials Act 2018 on clinical trial activity in Japan from 2018 to 2020: a retrospective database study using new and conventional Japanese registries
- Strategies to enhance recruitment and consent to intensive care studies: a qualitative study with researchers and patient–public involvement contributors
- Fifteen-minute consultation: an evidence-based approach to research without prior consent (deferred consent) in neonatal and paediatric critical care trials
- Synthesis of qualitative research studies regarding the factors surrounding UK critical care trial infrastructure
- A critical appraisal of clinical trials conducted and subsequent drug approvals in India and South Africa
- Trends in global clinical trial registration: an analysis of numbers of registered clinical trials in different parts of the world from 2004 to 2013
- Consent in emergency research: new regulations
- Current models, challenges and best practices for work conducted between European academic cooperative groups and industry