Cadaveric transplantation and living transplantation exist side by side. Both practices help to alleviate organ need. They provide us with two separate moral schemes. Is it rational to keep them apart? The cadaveric system is organised along strict, impartial lines, while the living system is inherently partial and local. The ethical justification for this partial scheme seems to be that it merely supplements the cadaveric scheme: partial transplants do not come at the expense of cadaveric impartiality, but in fact significantly reduce the waiting time for patients on the list for a cadaveric transplant.
This seemingly peaceful coexistence is challenged by new initiatives, among them living donation list exchange, and also the LifeSharers initiative, leading to practices that undermine cadaveric impartiality. Should we bemoan this fact, or should we move on towards a new balance in the relationship between cadaveric and living transplantation practices, towards a new moral weighing of impartial and partial values? I argue, against the background of a rapid growth of living donations, that we have good, ethical reasons—not only utilitarian ones—for giving the value of partiality a more prominent place in our policies.
Statistics from Altmetric.com
If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.
Competing interests: I declare to have no competing interests and have received no funding related to the subject of the paper.
Read the full text or download the PDF:
Other content recommended for you
- Live liver donation, ethics and practitioners: ‘I am between the two and if I do not feel comfortable about this situation, I cannot proceed’
- Kidneys on demand
- Join the Lone Kidney Club: incentivising live organ donation
- Self-interest, self-abnegation and self-esteem: towards a new moral economy of non-directed kidney donation
- Renal Transplantation
- Renal transplantation
- Liver transplantation in children: state of the art and future perspectives
- How altruistic organ donation may be (intrinsically) bad
- Organ transplantation and the Human Tissue Act
- Renal transplantation from living donors