Statistics from Altmetric.com
The ethical and legal challenges posed by assisted reproduction techniques are both profound and breathtaking, with most societies unable to fully comprehend one technique before another one, even more daring, emerges. The wrongful implantation of embryos in two women undergoing in vitro fertilisation (IVF) treatments at two separate clinics in the UK seriously vitiates the traditional concept of who is a parent. In one case, a patient’s embryos were wrongly implanted into another woman seeking similar treatment, and in the second, a woman’s eggs were fertilised using sperm from a man other than her husband.
In the first mix-up, neither member of the recipient couple was the genetic parent of the child, while in the second case, the recipient mother was the genetic mother and her husband was not the genetic father. The mix-ups resulted in litigation to determine who the rightful parents were. First, I will show in this paper that, although the outcome of the application of English law in both cases was in agreement with the outcome prescribed by basic principles of Islamic law and bioethics, that agreement is based on different reasoning in the two traditions. Next, I will show that the profound ethical implications of reproductive technologies begs for a more pluralistic bioethical discourse than the one-dimensional analysis applied by secular Western societies that currently dominates the enquiry, particularly as most Western societies are more or less multicultural and multireligious.
Box 1 Specialist terms and vocabulary
Concepts from the Qur’an
al-walad li’l-firash—child of the matrimonial bed
haquq adami—public/personal rights
haquq Allah—God’s rights
ibarah al-nass—literal or explicit meaning of a given text, which is borne out by its words
la tabanni fi al-Islam—adoption is not permissible in Islam
maslaha—consideration of the public interest
nasab—a person’s genealogy
Competing interests: None
↵*Present address: Molecular Biology & Bioinformatics, National Biotechnology Development Agency, Federal Ministry of Science & Technology, 16 Dunkofia Street, PMB 5118, Area 11, Garki, Abuja, Nigeria:
- in vitro fertilisation
If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.