Article Text
Abstract
Objectives: To investigate whether different methods of obtaining informed consent affected recruitment to a study of delirium in older, medically ill hospital inpatients.
Design: Open randomised study.
Setting: Acute medical service for older people in an inner city teaching hospital.
Participants: Patients 70 years or older admitted to the unit within three days of hospital admission randomised into two groups.
Intervention: Attempted recruitment of subjects to a study of the natural history of delirium. This was done by either (a) a formal test of capacity, followed by either a request for consent or an attempt at obtaining assent from a proxy, or (b) a combined informal capacity/consent process.
Main outcome measures: Prevalence and severity of delirium, and, as case mix measures, length of hospital stay and destination on discharge.
Results: Recruitment of subjects through establishing formal capacity and then informed consent was less successful (43.9% v 74% of those approached) and, compared with those recruited through the usual combined capacity/consent approach, yielded a sample with less cognitive impairment, lower severity of delirium, lower probability of case note diagnosis of delirium and lower rate of entering a care home.
Conclusions: Methods of obtaining informed consent may significantly influence the case mix of subjects recruited to a study of delirium. Stringent testing of capacity may exclude patients with delirium from studies, thus rendering findings less generalisable. A different method is necessary to achieve an ethical balance between respecting autonomy through obtaining adequate informed consent and avoiding sample bias.
- capacity
- consent
- formal assessment
- delirium
- geriatrics
Statistics from Altmetric.com
Footnotes
-
D Adamis was supported by the Bosher Memorial Bequest.
Read the full text or download the PDF:
Other content recommended for you
- Intranasal insulin for treatment of delirium in older hospitalised patients: study protocol for a randomised controlled trial
- An early prediction of delirium in the acute phase after stroke
- Delirium within the emergency care setting, occurrence and detection: a systematic review
- Protocol for validation of the 4AT, a rapid screening tool for delirium: a multicentre prospective diagnostic test accuracy study
- Treatment of postoperative delirium with continuous theta burst stimulation: study protocol for a randomised controlled trial
- Protocol for a single-centre prospective observational study of postoperative delirium following total joint arthroplasties among South East Asians
- Efficacy of halopeRIdol to decrease the burden of Delirium In adult Critically ill patiEnts (EuRIDICE): study protocol for a prospective randomised multi-centre double-blind placebo-controlled clinical trial in the Netherlands
- Detecting deficits of sustained visual attention in delirium
- Scheduled Prophylactic 6-Hourly IV AcetaminopheN to Prevent Postoperative Delirium in Older CaRdiac SurgicAl Patients (PANDORA): protocol for a multicentre randomised controlled trial
- Computerised cognitive training to improve cognition including delirium following coronary artery bypass grafting surgery: protocol for a blinded randomised controlled trial