Article Text
Abstract
In this paper a plea is made for an unprincipled approach to biomedical ethics, unprincipled of course just in the sense that the four principles are neither the start nor the end of the process of ethical reflection. While the four principles constitute a useful “checklist” approach to bioethics for those new to the field, and possibly for ethics committees without substantial ethical expertise approaching new problems, it is an approach which if followed by the bioethics community as a whole would, the author believes, lead to sterility and uniformity of approach of a quite mindbogglingly boring kind. Moreover, much of bioethics is not concerned with identifying the principles or values appropriate to a particular issue, but rather involves analysing the arguments that are so often already in play and which present themselves as offering solutions in one direction or another. Here, as I try to show in discussion of these four scenarios, the principles allow massive scope in interpretation and are, frankly, not wonderful as a means of detecting errors and inconsistencies in argument.
- four principles approach to medical ethics
- Raanan Gillon
- Thomas Beauchamp
- James Childress
- organ donation
- germline enhancement
Statistics from Altmetric.com
Footnotes
Read the full text or download the PDF:
Other content recommended for you
- Organ procurement: dead interests, living needs
- Human Germline Gene Therapy: Scientific, Moral and Political Issues
- Principlism and communitarianism
- Applying the four principles
- Reproductive and therapeutic cloning, germline therapy, and purchase of gametes and embryos: comments on Canadian legislation governing reproduction technologies
- “One man’s trash is another man’s treasure”: exploring economic and moral subtexts of the “organ shortage” problem in public views on organ donation
- Who is willing to take the risk? Assessing the readiness for living liver donation in the general German population
- Artificial gametes: new paths to parenthood?
- Shifting ethics: debating the incentive question in organ transplantation
- Advance commitment: an alternative approach to the family veto problem in organ procurement