Gillon is correct that the four principles provide a sound and useful way of analysing moral dilemmas. As he observes, the approach using these principles does not provide a unique solution to dilemmas. This can be illustrated by alternatives to Gillon’s own analysis of the four case scenarios. In the first scenario, a different set of factual assumptions could yield a different conclusion about what is required by the principle of beneficence. In the second scenario, although Gillon’s conclusion is correct, what is open to question is his claim that what society regards as the child’s best interest determines what really is in the child’s best interest. The third scenario shows how it may be reasonable for the principle of beneficence to take precedence over autonomy in certain circumstances, yet like the first scenario, the ethical conclusion relies on a set of empirical assumptions and predictions of what is likely to occur. The fourth scenario illustrates how one can draw different conclusions based on the importance given to the precautionary principle.
- four principles approach to medical ethics
- informed consent
- organ transplantation
- Raanan Gillon
- Jehovah’s Witnesses
Statistics from Altmetric.com
If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.
Other content recommended for you
- Bioethics: why philosophy is essential for progress
- Clinician gate-keeping in clinical research is not ethically defensible: an analysis
- Jehovah's Witnesses and autonomy: honouring the refusal of blood transfusions
- The ethics of policy writing: how should hospitals deal with moral disagreement about controversial medical practices?
- Principlism and communitarianism
- Adolescent autonomy revisited: clinicians need clearer guidance
- Assent as an ethical imperative in the treatment of ADHD
- Cultural sensitivity in paediatrics
- The ethics of sexual reorientation: what should clinicians and researchers do?
- Medical confidentiality and the protection of Jehovah's Witnesses' autonomous refusal of blood