Abstract
Background: Due to recent legislations on euthanasia and its current practice in the Netherlands and Belgium, issues of end-of-life medicine have become very vital in many European countries. In 2002, the Ethics Working Group of the German Association for Palliative Medicine (DGP) has conducted a survey among its physician members in order to evaluate their attitudes towards different end-of-life medical practices, such as euthanasia (EUT), physician-assisted suicide (PAS), and terminal sedation (TS). Methods: An anonymous questionnaire was sent to the 411 DGP physicians, consisting of 14 multiple choice questions on positions that might be adopted in different hypothetical scenarios on situations of “intolerable suffering” in end-of-life care. For the sake of clarification, several definitions and legal judgements of different terms used in the German debate on premature termination of life were included. For statistical analysis t-tests and Pearson-correlations were used. Results: The response rate was 61% (n=251). The proportions of the respondents who were opposed to legalizing different forms of premature termination of life were: 90% opposed to EUT, 75% to PAS, 94% to PAS for psychiatric patients. Terminal sedation was accepted by 94% of the members. The main decisional bases drawn on for the answers were personal ethical values, professional experience with palliative care, knowledge of alternative approaches, knowledge of ethical guidelines and of the national legal frame. Conclusions: In sharp contrast to similar surveys conducted in other countries, only a minority of 9.6% of the DGP physicians supported the legalization of EUT. The misuse of medical knowledge for inhumane killing in the Nazi period did not play a relevant role for the respondents’ negative attitude towards EUT. Palliative care needs to be stronger established and promoted within the German health care system in order to improve the quality of end-of-life situations which subsequently is expected to lead to decreasing requests for EUT by terminally ill patients.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Akademie für Ethik in der Medizin: 1998, ‘Patientenverfügung, Betreuungsverfügung, Vorsorgevollmacht. Eine Handreichung für Ärzte und Pflegende’, Working Group on Death and Dying (Arbeitsgruppe “Sterben und Tod”); the author F.S. Oduncu of the current article is an active member of this Working Group.
A.M. Ahmed M.M. Kheir A. Abdel Rahman N.H. Ahmed M.E. Abdalla (2001) ArticleTitle‘Attitudes Towards Euthanasia and Assisted Suicide Among Sudanese Doctors’ East Mediterr Health 7 IssueID3 551–555
T.L. Beauchamp J.F. Childress (2001) Principles of Biomedical Ethics EditionNumber5 Oxford University Press New York
J.A. Billings S.D. Block (1996) ArticleTitleSlow Euthanasia’ Journal of Palliative Care 12 21–30 Occurrence Handle9019033
N. Bittel H. Neuenschwander F. Stiefel (2002) ArticleTitle“Euthanasia”: A Survey by the Swiss Association for Palliatve Care’ Support Care Cancer 10 265–271 Occurrence Handle10.1007/s00520-001-0325-0 Occurrence Handle12029425
B. Broeckaert J.M. Nunez Olarte (2002) ‘Sedation in Palliative Care: Facts and Concepts’ H ten Have D Clark (Eds) The Ethics of Palliative Care: European Perspectives, Facing Death series Open University Press Buckingham 166–180
Bundesärztekammer: 1998, ‘Grundsätze der Bundesärztekammer zur Ärztlichen Sterbebegleitung’, Deutsches Ärzteblatt 95, A-2365-2366. (For the English translation see: Principles of the German Medical Association Concerning Terminal Medical Care: 2000, Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 25, 254–258).
InstitutionalAuthorNameBundesärztekammer (1999) ArticleTitle‘Handreichung für Ärzte zum Umgang mit Patientenverfügungen’ Deutsches Ärzteblatt 96 A 2720–2721
Bundesgerichtshof: 2003, Beschluss vom 17. März 2003, XII. Zivilsenat: XII ZB 2/03.
I.R. Byock (1994) ArticleTitle‘When Suffering persists’ Journal of Palliative Care 10 8–13
A.C. Carver B.B. Vickrey J.L. Bernat C. Keran S.P. Ringel K.M. Foley (1999) ArticleTitle‘End-of-Life Care: A Survey of US Neurologists’ Attitudes, Behavior, and Knowledge’ Neurology 53 IssueID2 284–293 Occurrence Handle10430415
S. Chater R. Viola J Paterson Jarvis (1998) ArticleTitle‘Sedation for Intractable Distress in the Dying–A Survey of Experts’ Palliative Medicine 12 225–269 Occurrence Handle10.1191/026921698671831786
J.D. Cowan T.W. Palmer (2002) ArticleTitle‘Practical Guide to Palliative Sedation’ Curr Oncol Rep 4 IssueID3 242–249 Occurrence Handle11937015
J.D. Cowan D. Walsh (2001) ArticleTitle‘Terminal Sedation in Palliative Medicine–Definition and Review of the Literature’ Support Care Cancer 9 IssueID6 403–407 Occurrence Handle10.1007/s005200100235 Occurrence Handle11585266
G.E. Dickinson C.J. Lancaster D. Clark S.H. Ahmedzai W. Noble (2002) ArticleTitle‘U.K. Physicians Attitudes Toward Active Voluntary Euthanasia and Physician-Assisted Suicide’ Death Stud 26 IssueID6 479–490 Occurrence Handle10.1080/074811802760139003 Occurrence Handle12136881
G. Di Mola P. Borsellino C. Brunelli M. Gallucci A. Gamba M. Lusignani C. Regazzo A. Santosuosso M. Tamburini F. Toscani (1996) ArticleTitle‘Attitudes Toward Euthanasia of Physician Members of the Italian Society of Palliative Care’ Ann Oncol 7 907–911 Occurrence Handle9006740
Doctor-Assisted-Suicide: 2004, ‘A Guide to Web Sites and the Literature, http://www.lwc.edu/administrative/library/suic.htm.
Document nr. 2-244/26 of the Belgian Senate, session 2000–2001, 9 July 2001.
C.D. Douglas I.H. Kerridge K.J. Rainbird J.R. McPhee L. Hancock A.D. Spigelman (2001) ArticleTitle‘The Intention to Hasten Death: A Survey of Attitudes and Practices of Surgeons in Australia’ eMJA 175 511–515 Occurrence Handle11795535
R.E. Enck (1991) ArticleTitle‘Drug Induced Terminal Sedation for Symptom Control’ Am J Hosp Palliat Care 8 3–5
Enquete Kommission des Deutschen Bundestages: ‘Recht und Ethik der modernen Medizin’: 2004, http://www.bundestag.de/gremien/medi-2zwischen.html.
D. Essinger (2003) ArticleTitle‘Attitudes of Tennessee Physicians Toward Euthanasia and Assisted Death’ South Med J 96 IssueID5 427–435 Occurrence Handle10.1097/01.SMJ.0000051144.80620.C1 Occurrence Handle12911179
A.P. Folker N. Holtug A.B. Jensen K. Kappel J.K. Nielsen M. Norup (1996) ArticleTitle‘Experiences and Attitudes Towards End-of-Life-Decisions Amongst Danish Physicians’ Bioethics 10 233–249 Occurrence Handle11657395
R. Forde O.G. Aasland E. Falkum (1997) ArticleTitle‘The Ethics of Euthanasia–Attitudes and Practice Among Norwegian Physicians’ Soc Sci Med 11 140–144
C.J. Furst K. Hagenfeldt (2002) ArticleTitle‘End-of-Life Sedation–Definition and Clinical Guidelines Needed’ Lakartidningen 99 IssueID39 3830–3835 Occurrence Handle12395532
Geißendörfer, S.E., A. Tietze and A. Simon. In Cooperation with Lipp, V., A.T. May, F. Oduncu, K.W. Schmidt and T. Wernstedt: 2004, ‘Sicherung der Patientenautonomie am Ende des Lebens. Gesetzliche Regelung der Patientenverfügung als Rechtsinstitut und Änderung des Strafgesetzbuches. Betreuungsrechtliche Praxis, in press.
Goldstein-Shirley, J. and P.G. Fine: 2001, “Ethics of Total Sedation”, “Total Sedation Educational Resources Draft”, Prepared by a Task Force of the NHPCP Ethics Committee’, Session 8A: 3–8, March 25, 2001.
K. Hedberg D. Hopkins M. Kohn (2003) ArticleTitle‘Five Years of Legal Physician-Assisted Suicide in Oregon’ New England Journal of Medicine 348 IssueID10 961–964 Occurrence Handle10.1056/NEJM200303063481022 Occurrence Handle12621146
E.L. Krakauer R.T. Penson R.D. Truog L.A. King B.A. Chabner T.J. Lynch (2000) ArticleTitle‘Sedation for Intractable Distress of a Dying Patient’ The Oncologist 5 53–62 Occurrence Handle10.1634/theoncologist.5-1-53 Occurrence Handle10706650
J.T. Mangan (1949) ArticleTitle‘An Historical Analysis of the Principle of Double Effect’ Theological Studies 10 41–61
L.J. Materstvedt D. Clark J. Ellershaw R. Forde A.-M. Boeck Gravgaard H.C. Müller-Busch J. Porta i Sales C.-H. Rapin (2003) ArticleTitle‘Euthanasia and Physician- assisted Suicide: A View from an EAPC Ethics Task Force’ Palliative Medicine 17 97–101 Occurrence Handle10.1191/0269216303pm673oa Occurrence Handle12701848
K.J. McGlade L. Slaney B.P. Bunting A.G. Gallagher (2000) ArticleTitle‘Voluntary Euthanasia in Northern Ireland: General Practitioners’ Beliefs, Experiences, and Actions’ Br J Gen Pract 50 IssueID459 794–797 Occurrence Handle11127168
T. Morita S. Tsuneto Y. Shima (2002a) ArticleTitle‘Definition of Sedation for Symptom Relief: A Systematic Literature Review and a Proposal of Operational Criteria’ Journal of Pain Symptom Management 24 IssueID4 447–453 Occurrence Handle10.1016/S0885-3924(02)00499-2
T. Morita K. Hirai Y. Okazaki (2002b) ArticleTitle‘Preferences for Palliative Sedation Therapy in the Japanese General Population’ Journal of Palliative Medicine 5 IssueID3 375–385 Occurrence Handle10.1089/109662102320135261
T. Morita J. Tsuneto S. Inoue S. Chihara (2000) ArticleTitle‘Terminal Sedation for Existential Distress’ American Journal of Hosp Palliative Care 17 IssueID3 189–195
T. Morita S. Tsuneto Y. Shima (2001) ArticleTitle‘Proposed Definitions for Terminal Sedation’ Lancet 358 335–336 Occurrence Handle10.1016/S0140-6736(01)05515-5
H.C. Müller-Busch E. Klaschik F.S. Oduncu T. Schindler S. Woskanjan (2003a) ArticleTitle‘Euthanasie bei unerträglichem Leid Eine Studie der Deutschen Gesellschaft für Palliativmedizin zum Thema Sterbehilfe im Jahre 2002’ Zeitschrift für Palliativmedizin IssueID4 75–84
H.C. Müller-Busch I. Andres T. Jehser (2003b) ArticleTitle‘Sedation in Palliative Care–A Critical Analysis of 7 years Experience’ BMC Palliative Care 2 2 Occurrence Handle10.1186/1472-684X-2-2
Nationaler Ethikrat: 2004, http://www.nationalerethikrat.de.
F.S. Oduncu (2003a) ArticleTitle‘Euthanasie bei unheilbarem Leid?’ Stimmen der Zeit 221 IssueID2 121–130
F.S. Oduncu (2003b) ArticleTitle‘Euthanasia: Killing as Due Care?’ Wiener Medizinische Wochenschrift 153 387–391 Occurrence Handle10.1007/s10354-003-0020-5
Oduncu, F.S.: 2003c, ‘Sterbehilfe und Sterbebegleitung’, Soziales Seminar 2/2003 (Oktober).
F.S. Oduncu (2002) ArticleTitle‘Belgien verabschiedet Euthanasie-Gesetz’ Zeitschrift für medizinische Ethik 48 IssueID3 310–312
F.S. Oduncu (2001) ArticleTitle‘Begleiten statt töten!’ Stimmen der Zeit 219 IssueID8 520–532
F. Oduncu (1999) ArticleTitle‘Sterbebegleitung und Sterbehilfe’ Stimmen der Zeit 217 541–554
Oduncu, F.S. and W. Eisenmenger: 2003, ‘Geringe Lebensqualität. Die finstere Praxis der Sterbehilfe in Holland – bis hin zum Mord’, Süddeutsche Zeitung no. 162, Feuilleton, p. 11.
F.S. Oduncu W. Eisenmenger (2002) ArticleTitle‘Euthanasie, Sterbehilfe, Sterbebegleitung. Eine kritische Bestandsaufnahme im internationalen Vergleich’ Medizinrecht 20 IssueID7 327–337 Occurrence Handle10.1007/s00350-002-0723-4
Oduncu, F.S., S. Hesse, H. Dietzfelbinger, W. Wibmer and R. Nun: 2004a, ‘Sterbebegleitung und Seelsorge’, in: V. Heinemann (ed.), Supportive Maßnahmen und symptomorientierte Therapie in der Hämatologie und Onkologie, 2nd edn. Schriftreihen des Tumorzentrums München, in press.
Oduncu, F.S., G.D. Borasio, M. Hussain, U. Schroth and W. Eisenmenger: 2004b, ‘Patientenverfügung und Testament’, in: V. Heinemann (ed.), Supportive Maßnahmen und symptomorientierte Therapie in der Hämatologie und Onkologie, 2nd edn. Schriftreihen des Tumorzentrums München, in press.
Oregon Death with Dignity Act: Oregon Revised Statute 127.800–127.995; 1997.
T.E. Quill R. Dresser D.W. Brock (1997) ArticleTitle‘The Rule of Double Effect - A Critique of its Role in End-of-Life Decision Making’ New England Journal of Medicine 337 1768–1771 Occurrence Handle10.1056/NEJM199712113372413 Occurrence Handle9392707
J. Ramirez Rivera R. Rodriguez Y. Otero Igaravidez (2000) ArticleTitle‘Attitudes Towards Euthanasia, Assisted Suicide and Termination of Life-Sustaining Treatment of Puerto Rican Medical Students, Medical Residents, and Faculty’ Bol Asoc Med P R 92 (1-3) 18–21
P.C. Rousseau (2002) ArticleTitle‘Palliative Sedation’ American Journal of Hosp Palliative Care 19 IssueID5 295–297
P. Rousseau (2001) ArticleTitle‘Existential Suffering and Palliative Sedation: A Brief Commentary with a Proposal for Clinical Guidelines’ American Journal of Hosp and Palliative Care 18 IssueID3 151–153
O.P. Ryynanen M. Myllykangas M. Viren H. Heino (2002) ArticleTitle‘Attitudes Towards Euthanasia Among Physicians, nurses and the General Public in Finland’ Public Health 116 IssueID6 322–331 Occurrence Handle10.1016/S0033-3506(02)00556-5 Occurrence Handle12407471
Strätling, M., V. Lipp, A.T. May, K. Kutzer, P. Glogner, U. Schlaudraff, G. Neuman and A. Simon: 2003, ‘Passive und indirekte Sterbehilfe. Eine praxisorientierte Analyse des Regelungsbedarfs gesetzlicher Rahmenbedingungen in Deutschland, Empfehlungen einer interdisziplinären Arbeitsgruppe in der Akademie für Ethik in der Medizin e.V.’, Göttingen, June 2003.
Suizid-Tourismus: 2004. http://www.jesus.ch/www/index. php/D/190/9189.
Swiss Association for Palliative Care: 2001, ‘Position Paper of the SAPC with Regard to the Debate on Euthanasia’, Lausanne: SAPC.
T Tannsjo (2000) ArticleTitle‘Terminal Sedation–A Possible Compromise in the Euthanasia Debate?’ Bulletin Med Ethics 163 13–22
Termination of Life on Request and Assisted Suicide Act: 2000, Review Procedures for the Termination of Life on Request and Assisted Suicide and Amendment of the Criminal Code and the Burial and Cremation Act. Chapter II, Section 2.
E. Valverius T. Nilstun B. Nilsson (2000) ArticleTitle‘Palliative Care, Assisted Suicide and Euthanasia’ Palliative Medicine 14 141–148 Occurrence Handle10.1191/026921600667894103 Occurrence Handle10829148
M.J. Verhoef T.D. Kinsella (1996) ArticleTitle‘Alberta Euthanasia Survey: 3 Year Follow-Up’ Can Med Assoc Journal 155 885–890
O. Walton S.M. Weinstein (2002) ArticleTitle‘Sedation for Comfort at End of Life’ Curr Pain Headache Rep 6 IssueID3 197–201 Occurrence Handle12003690
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Müller-busch, H.C., Oduncu, F.S., Woskanjan, S. et al. Attitudes on euthanasia, physician-assisted suicide and terminal sedation -- A survey of the members of the German Association for Palliative Medicine. Med Health Care Philos 7, 333–339 (2005). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11019-004-9349-9
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11019-004-9349-9