Table 2

Students reporting an objection (religious, non-religious or both) to a total of 11 procedures

ProcedureStudents reporting objection to procedure (%)Students who would not perform procedure (%)Muslim students reporting objection to procedure (%)Muslim students who would not perform procedure (%)
Abortion for congenital abnormalities before 24 weeks22.2 (n=160)15.8 (n=114)49.2 (n=30)32.8 (n=20)
Abortion for congenital abnormalities after 24 weeks43.7 (n=314)29.5 (n=212)72.6 (n=45)45.2 (n=28)
Abortion for failed contraception before 24 weeks31.9 (n=230)23.5 (n=170)73.0 (n=46)60.3 (n=38)
Abortion for a raped minor before 24 weeks13.1 (n=94)10.5 (n=75)16.4 (n=10)11.5 (n=7)
Abortion for a raped minor after 24 weeks31.2 (n=224)19.8 (n=142)37.7 (n=23)26.2 (n=16)
Learning about the moral arguments surrounding abortion at medical school1.4 (n=10)0.3 (n=2)4.6 (n=3)0.0 (n=0)
Prescription of birth control to a female who is deemed competent4.4 (n=32)1.9 (n=14)6.4 (n=4)4.8 (n=3)
Examining or treating a patient intoxicated with alcohol8.5 (n=62)1.2 (n=9)17.2 (n=11)1.6 (n=1)
Learning about the clinical impact of alcohol at medical school0.5 (n=4)0.0 (n=0)1.6 (n=1)0.0 (n=0)
Examining or treating a patient intoxicated with recreational drugs9.2 (n=67)1.6 (n=12)18.5 (n=12)1.5 (n=1)
Intimately examining a person of the opposite sex5.4 (n=39)1.1 (n=8)36.0 (n=23)7.8 (n=5)
  • Press attention has recently been focused on the issue of conscientious objection within Muslim medical students,6 and therefore the results of the Muslim students in the study are shown separately.