Article Text
Abstract
Background Extant surveys of people's attitudes towards human reproductive cloning focus on moral judgements alone, not emotional reactions or sentiments. This is especially important given that some (especially Leon Kass) have argued against such cloning on the ground that it engenders widespread negative emotions, like disgust, that provide a moral guide.
Objective To provide some data on emotional reactions to human cloning, with a focus on repugnance, given its prominence in the literature.
Methods This brief mixed-method study measures the self-reported attitudes and emotions (positive or negative) towards cloning from a sample of participants in the USA.
Results Most participants condemned cloning as immoral and said it should be illegal. The most commonly reported positive sentiment was by far interest/curiosity. Negative emotions were much more varied, but anxiety was the most common. Only about a third of participants selected disgust or repugnance as something they felt, and an even smaller portion had this emotion come to mind prior to seeing a list of options.
Conclusions Participants felt primarily interested and anxious about human reproductive cloning. They did not primarily feel disgust or repugnance. This provides initial empirical evidence that such a reaction is not appropriately widespread.
- Cloning
- Moral Psychology
- Reproductive Medicine
- Scientific Research
Statistics from Altmetric.com
Other content recommended for you
- Reproductive cloning in humans and therapeutic cloning in primates: is the ethical debate catching up with the recent scientific advances?
- What exactly is an exact copy? And why it matters when trying to ban human reproductive cloning in Australia
- Just another reproductive technology? The ethics of human reproductive cloning as an experimental medical procedure
- The role of emotion in ethics and bioethics: dealing with repugnance and disgust
- Human reproductive cloning and reasons for deprivation
- A resource-based version of the argument that cloning is an affront to human dignity
- Cell phoney: human cloning after Quintavalle
- Why the apparent haste to clone humans?
- Reproductive and therapeutic cloning, germline therapy, and purchase of gametes and embryos: comments on Canadian legislation governing reproduction technologies
- Illegal beings. Human cloning and the law