Article Text
Abstract
Does the position of the Roman Catholic Church on contraception also imply that the usage of condoms by HIV-discordant couples is illicit? A standard argument is to appeal to the doctrine of double effect to condone such usage, but this meets with the objection that there exists an alternative action that brings about the good effect—namely, abstinence. I argue against this objection, because an HIV-discordant couple does not bring about any bad outcome through condom usage—there is no disrespect displayed for the generative function of sex. One might retort that the badness of condom usage consists in thwarting the unitive function of sex. I argue that also this objection cannot be upheld. In conclusion, if there are no in-principle objections against condom usage for HIV-discordant couples, then policies that deny access to condoms to such couples are indefensible. HIV-discordant couples have a right to continue consummating their marriage in a manner that is minimally risky and this right cannot be trumped by utilitarian concerns that the distribution of condoms might increase promiscuity and along with it the HIV infection rate.
Statistics from Altmetric.com
Footnotes
Competing interests None.
Provenance and Peer review Not commissioned; externally peer reviewed.
Linked Articles
- The concise argument
Other content recommended for you
- Weakening the ethical distinction between euthanasia, palliative opioid use and palliative sedation
- The role of the principle of double effect in ethics education at US medical schools and its potential impact on pain management at the end of life
- A response to critics: weakening the ethical distinction between euthanasia, palliative opioid use and palliative sedation
- Embryo loss and double effect
- Double effect: a useful rule that alone cannot justify hastening death
- The concise argument
- Can facilitated aid in dying be permitted by ‘double effect’? Some reflections from a recent New Zealand case
- Strengthening the ethical distinction between euthanasia, palliative opioid use and palliative sedation
- Factors associated with consistent condom use and STIs among foreign female entertainment workers: results from a cross-sectional survey in Singapore
- Design, measurement, and analytical considerations for testing hypotheses relative to condom effectiveness against non-viral STIs