Article Text
Abstract
In the search for a globally binding ethical minimal consensus in dealing with research on human beings the awareness of the cultural specificity of such questions will be of central importance. France provides a good example of such cultural specificities. Three basic structures of French discussion on research ethics can be enumerated: first the particular weight placed on therapeutic benefit, second a particular accentuation on freedom and voluntarism, and third its lesser attention to the aspect of ability to give consent. The weak emphasis on the ability to give consent is rooted as much in the traditionally paternalistically imbued physician-patient relationship as in the French legal system, in which the doctrine of consent is not given the fundamental position of importance found in the Anglo-Saxon countries. As an important Roman country, a different accentuation in the ethical discussion on research on humans can be recognised, a discussion in which for a long time the right of self determination was less of a criterion for decision than the teleology of medical action. It is precisely this aspect of latent cultural influence in ethical convictions which is of decisive importance for future discussion on research on humans.
- Research Ethics
- France
- philosophy of medicine
- research on human subjects
Statistics from Altmetric.com
Footnotes
Read the full text or download the PDF:
Other content recommended for you
- Legislative regulation and ethical governance of medical research in different European Union countries
- The Judgment of the German Federal Constitutional Court regarding assisted suicide: a template for pluralistic states?
- Managing self-harm: the legal issues
- Doctors’ willingness to give honest answers about end-of-life practices: a cross-sectional study
- Ethics committees and the legality of research
- Drafting guidelines for the withholding or withdrawing of life sustaining treatment in critically ill children and neonates
- Organ retention and return: problems of consent
- New European guidelines for the use of stored human biological materials in biomedical research
- Military medical research in Britain and the USA: the challenge of informed consent
- The courts' role in decisions about medical treatment