Article Text
Abstract
The distinction between clinical practice and surgical research may seem trivial, but this distinction can become a complex issue when innovative surgeries are substituted for standard care without patient knowledge. Neither the novelty nor the risk of a new surgical procedure adequately defines surgical research. Some institutions tacitly allow the use of new surgical procedures in series of patients without informing individuals that they are participating in a scientific study, as long as no written protocol or hypothesis exists. Institutions can justify this practice by viewing human research in narrow terms as an activity outlined in a formal protocol. Application of limited definitions, however, erodes patients' rights and risks losing public confidence in how biomedical research is conducted. I propose an operational definition of human research also be recognised. Enforcing more rigid and less ambiguous guidelines of human research may curtail enrolment into some studies, but it will also protect patients from being used as subjects without their knowledge.
- Experimental surgery
- innovative surgery
- medical ethics
- surgical research
Statistics from Altmetric.com
Footnotes
-
Curtis Margo, MD, MPH, is an Ophthalmologist, a Pathologist and a Partner in the Watson Clinic LLP, Lakeland, Florida USA.
Read the full text or download the PDF:
Other content recommended for you
- Non-equivalent stringency of ethical review in the Baltic States: a sign of a systematic problem in Europe?
- The Applicability of Lean and Six Sigma Techniques to Clinical and Translational Research
- Clinical Research From Proposal to Implementation
- Nature and governance of veterinary clinical research conducted in the UK
- GEORGE M. O'BRIEN KIDNEY RESEARCH CORE CENTERS (P30): RFA-DK-11-008
- DEVELOPMENT AND TRANSLATION OF MEDICAL TECHNOLOGIES TO REDUCE HEALTH DISPARITIES (R43/R44): RFA-EB-12-001
- Institutional Clinical and Translational Science Award (U54): RFA-TR-12-006
- Developing capacity to protect human research subjects in a post-conflict, resource-constrained setting: procedures and prospects
- Legislative regulation and ethical governance of medical research in different European Union countries
- International requirements for consent in biobank research: qualitative review of research guidelines