Article Text
Abstract
Physicians are increasingly confronted with the consequences of allocation policies. In several countries, physicians have been assigned a gatekeeper role for secondary health care. Many ethicists oppose this assignment for several reasons, concentrating on the harm the intrusion of societal arguments would inflict on doctor-patient relations. It is argued that these arguments rest on a distinction of spheres of values and of rationality, without taking into account the mixing of values and rationalities that takes place in everyday medical practice. If medical practice, then, does not follow a single, pure rationality, can it also incorporate the societal rationality of the gatekeeper role?
Using a case from general practice, I try to show how physicians may integrate societal arguments into their practice in a morally acceptable way. A version of the model of reflective equilibrium and especially Beauchamp and Childress's safeguards, may be helpful both to analyse and teach such balancing of values and rationalities.
- Allocation
- gatekeeper
- physician-patient relations
- justice
- balancing
- ethics
Statistics from Altmetric.com
Footnotes
-
Dick L Willems, MD, PhD is a General Practitioner and a Senior Researcher in Ethics at the Department of General Practice, Division of Public Health, Academic Medical Centre and University of Amsterdam, Amsterdam, the Netherlands.
Read the full text or download the PDF:
Other content recommended for you
- The bioethical principles and Confucius’ moral philosophy
- Principlism or narrative ethics: must we choose between them?
- Justification of principles for healthcare priority setting: the relevance and roles of empirical studies exploring public values
- Will international human rights subsume medical ethics? Intersections in the UNESCO Universal Bioethics Declaration
- Why not common morality?
- What do patients value in their hospital care? A response to Joffe et al
- Three pitfalls of accountable healthcare rationing
- Dotting the I's and crossing the T's: autonomy and/or beneficence? The ‘fetus as a patient’ in maternal–fetal surgery
- Pharmacist conscience clauses and access to oral contraceptives
- How should doctors approach patients? A Confucian reflection on personhood